Blog post

A reason why competent graphics designers design ugly templates?

July 5, 2011 · by Jan Schultink
← all posts

Most corporate PowerPoint templates are ugly and take up too much screen real estate. Most corporate PowerPoint templates are designed by professional graphics designers. This does not make sense? I just realized, here is probably why: graphics designers design the template on an empty screen (or Microsoft’s bullet point opening screen). Uh oh, need to fill up that white space with something interesting.

The solution: next time your PowerPoint template is up for renewal, hand the graphics designer a real slide deck and tell her: put this presentation in a new template. My guess is you would get far better results.

PowerPointPresentation designTemplates

About this blog

Notes on all things presentations — design, storytelling, and AI workflows.

Subscribe now to never miss a post.

RSS

About SlideMagic

A platform for business presentations.

A free student plan is available.

9 comments

Nolan Haims2011-07-05 11:42:35
You're spot on as I've seen this in action more times than I care to remember. I would lay perhaps even more blame on management (non-designers) who generally cannot understand that it's content that needs to be designed, not a frame around and independent of that content (which is what I think most "templates" are.)

But I would also lay blame on many talented print designers whose design training often flies out of the window the moment they open up PowerPoint: They suddenly seems to forget about color, typography, composition, negative space, etc. Upon seeing this, I've often suggested just approaching slides like billboard design, which occasionally helps.

But to lay further blame on those print designers, I think a lot of them often just don't care—to suggest using real content, to use their design training, to educate themselves and their bosses—because, "it's just PowerPoint." I think this blog post from a print designer nicely sums up the attitude of far too many graphic designers:

I admit I may have gone off a bit harshly on "Homegirl," but I just couldn't resist..
Anonymous2011-07-05 07:25:39
Good advice, Jan! Starting work for a new client I usually ask for their current presentation, create a few slides and then start to work on a new template, having already some content for 4-5 slides (some text, tables, charts etc.).
Concerning the lack of free space: I've recently received from a client their corporate ppt master which included (on a regular slide): one title, 2 'overtitles' in smaller font, 2 subtitles (in an even smaller font) and 2 places reserved for subscripts at the bottom. Plus some great-looking graphics flowing down from the logo on the top right down to the bottom. The result: it left me with about 35-40% of the slide space for content. Again, I had to delete it and start from scratch ;-)
Best regards,
Piotr
Oliver (Rethink Presentations)2011-07-05 08:27:51
I'd like to see that the designer doesn't just hand in a template, but a guideline on how to create presentations - including storytelling, etc. That would be cool!

Oliver
Alessandra2011-07-05 06:50:58
Well said!
I have done presentations for a company whose template was just as you described, but employees accept what comes from supposed experts and don't realize how a bad template limits space and hinders effectiveness.
Jan Schultink2011-07-05 13:44:50
Nolan,

I agree with you about your perspectives on designers. They should jump on this opportunity of pushing print-quality PPT into the enterprise.
Simon2011-07-05 16:30:10
No. Nononononnonnono.... don't give the presentation to a designer in the first place! :) Just do the damned presentation without a template.

Hand on heart, after years of doing this for a living and seeing hundreds and hundreds of templates, I've never seen one that made the presentation better than a well designed presentation would do if the presenter had done it themselves from scratch.

(On the other hand I've seen some templates used to avoid the crap presenter putting 12 point Times Roman text up on the screens! :) )
Andy Gurnett2011-07-05 03:17:05
Yes, I think that's bang on and great advice. How about doing the design work using a projector too? Instead of a gorgeous LCD display that shows subtle nuances between shades that an audience will never see.
Arte R2011-07-05 13:39:38
You have a point. There one thing additional to consider in this. The designer doesn't usually have the final word. An internal team or some one in senior management goes through and approves the design. The designer ends up giving in to their likes.
Sandy Johnson2011-07-05 14:01:55
Great blog, great thread.

Sharing in your pain,